Beyond the label: Direct sellers’ claims are in the spotlight

Recent enforcement activity by the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is a timely reminder for New Zealand direct selling businesses that regulators are increasingly focused on how products are marketed online, particularly where health, wellness and income-related claims are involved.
The FTC has recently pursued a number of health and wellness companies for allegedly making unsubstantiated health claims, using misleading testimonials, and overstating product benefits.
Recent FTC enforcement action
The FTC’s recent action against Amare Global Holdings Inc, a multilevel marketer of dietary supplements, alleges that three Amare principals made false, misleading and unsubstantiated claims that their products could treat or mitigate depression, anxiety and ADHD in children and adults. The FTC alleges the products were marketed as "clinically proven" or "scientifically backed" and claimed they could reduce the risk of suicide in children. The FTC also alleged that Amare and its recruiters made deceptive earnings claims by telling prospective brand partners that they could earn at least US$500 a month, regardless of prior multilevel marketing experience or the size of their social media following.
A similar enforcement action was taken against the operators of Forever Living Products International. These operators are now prohibited under a stipulated order from making deceptive earnings claims. The tactics allegedly used to promote the business opportunity were classic aspirational selling: images of luxury cars and giant cheques, coupled with claims that participants could replace a full-time job. Yet the FTC alleged that at least 77% of participants in each of the last five years received no compensation and more than 89% of new participants had not recouped their initial start-up cost of over US$300 after two years. The order also requires any earnings claims to be substantiated. No monetary penalty was imposed.
Amare and Forever Living are not isolated examples. In September 2026, Amway and two affiliated recruiting groups agreed to pay US$225 million under a proposed order for misrepresenting likely earnings. The sum is the largest monetary recovery the FTC has obtained from a multilevel marketer. It was alleged that Amway and its affiliates misrepresented potential earnings, pressured independent business owners to buy products that were difficult to sell, and instructed them to falsely report product sales to make the opportunity appear to be about selling products rather than recruiting. A common thread is that regulators looked beyond the company's own materials to what distributors said and showed on social media, and to whether the company held evidence to support what was claimed.
Enforcement trends in New Zealand
Similar themes are emerging in New Zealand. The Commerce Commission has identified misleading online sales conduct as an enforcement priority, with a particular focus on online reviews, influencer marketing, subscription models and unsubstantiated claims. See our previous FYI on misleading online sales conduct here.
For direct sellers, the key message is that compliance extends well beyond product labels. Claims made on websites, social media, distributor pages, emails, testimonials, customer reviews and influencer content may all be attributed to the business. The overall impression created for consumers matters, including wording, imagery and omissions.
Health and wellness businesses should take particular care with health and potentially therapeutic claims. Claims that a product can treat, prevent or alleviate a disease, medical condition or symptom should be carefully reviewed to ensure they are legally permissible and supported by appropriate evidence. Even where a claim is framed as a personal testimonial or distributor experience, regulators may view it as a product claim if consumers are likely to interpret it as evidence of efficacy. Similarly, before and after images, customer success stories and influencer endorsements can create an impression that must be capable of substantiation.
Practical steps for direct sellers to take
In light of recent FTC enforcement action and the Commerce Commission's stated priorities, direct selling businesses should ensure the following measures are in place to help keep their marketing accurate, evidence-based and consistent with New Zealand consumer protection requirements:
Review all product, health and earnings claims across websites, social media, emails, brochures, presentations and distributor materials, and remove or amend anything that cannot be substantiated.
Hold the scientific, clinical or other evidence supporting each claim (including "clinically proven" or "scientifically backed" statements) and check that it supports the claim as consumers are likely to understand it.
Avoid lifestyle imagery or income statements that suggest typical results unless they are accurate and substantiated. Accompany earnings claims with a clear income disclosure that reflects what participants typically earn and the costs involved.
Adopt a written code of conduct and social media guidelines for distributors, with a list of approved and prohibited claims, and make acceptance a condition of participation.
Provide onboarding and refresher training for distributors and staff on permitted claims, testimonials and disclosure, and keep records of who has been trained.
Ensure testimonials are genuine and typical or are clearly qualified, do not fabricate or selectively filter reviews, and require clear disclosure of any paid or incentivised endorsement. Have written agreements with influencers.
Check subscription sign-up and cancellation processes, pricing and discount statements, and online checkout flows for accuracy and transparency.
The bottom line
A compliant product and label are no longer enough. Regulators are looking at the entire digital sales journey, and direct selling businesses should ensure that all product, health and wellness claims made across their marketing ecosystem are well substantiated and capable of withstanding regulatory scrutiny.
Get in touch
If you need help with reviewing your claims, please contact our sales and marketing law team.
Special thanks to Juliet Bing-Harmon for her assistance with this article
Contacts

Richard Watts





