Australia is proposing reforms to its privacy laws, which could mean more stringent requirements on New Zealand organisations doing business across the Tasman.

The proposals could also signal a direction for change in New Zealand’s Privacy Act, amid longstanding calls for stricter controls and penalties.

Key takeaways

  • NZ compliance would not be enough: affected New Zealand businesses would need to meet the new requirements even where their practices comply with NZ privacy law. Organisations using personal or behavioural data for profiling, personalisation or targeted advertising are likely to feel the biggest impact.

  • A new “fair and reasonable” test: the reforms would introduce an overarching requirement that the collection, use and disclosure of personal information be “fair and reasonable” requiring specific consideration of legislated factors including risks of harm and proportionality.

  • Consent requirement: Collecting sensitive information, or trading personal information (including for direct marketing), would require consent that is voluntary, informed, current, specific and unambiguous.

  • Easy opt-outs and a right to erasure: direct marketing communications would need a simple way to opt out. Individuals could also ask large digital platforms to erase their personal information.

  • Data breach obligations: enhanced obligations would apply to organisations affected by data breaches, including a statutory 72-hour window to notify the regulator in serious cases.

In this BusinessDesk piece partner Karen Ngan discusses what these proposals could mean for NZ businesses operating in Australia, as well as for the future of our own Privacy Act.

Key proposals and implications for New Zealand

The Australian Government released draft legislation reflecting changes to “modernise and strengthen Australia’s privacy law for the digital age” in August 2026.  Consultation closed in September and the Bill remains under consideration.

Some of the key differences between Australian and New Zealand privacy law that could arise if the reforms are adopted are outlined below. In practical terms, they would see New Zealand businesses operating both here and in Australia held to a higher standard across the Tasman.

Fair and reasonable test

Under the proposed Australian reforms, the collection, use and disclosure of personal information would be required to be “fair and reasonable in the circumstances”. This would involve specific consideration of matters such as individuals’ reasonable expectations, data minimisation, genuine choice, privacy impacts, risks of harm and proportionality.

While obligations under the New Zealand Act reflect elements of fairness and reasonableness, it does not contain an equivalent overarching test.

Consent requirement

The Australian proposals expressly require “consent” for the collection of sensitive personal information and before personal information is “traded” (including disclosed for monetary or other consideration or for direct marketing purposes).  Consent may be express or implied but must be voluntary, informed, current, specific and unambiguous.  

The New Zealand Act does not contain an equivalent “consent” provision, focussing instead on transparency principles, meaning that affected organisations would need to review their information collection notices and practices.

Right to erasure

A right to erasure is well-established in the privacy laws of numerous jurisdictions but does not exist in New Zealand. The Australian reforms would introduce a limited right for individuals to request the erasure of their personal information. As currently proposed, that right would apply only against “large digital platforms” meeting prescribed revenue or user-number thresholds and would be subject to exceptions.

Direct marketing

The proposed amendments would require all direct marketing communications to provide a simple means to opt out of such communications, and information on how to do so. The form would depend on the type of communication but could include opt-out link or instructions on how to manage ad preferences or settings.

Data breach obligations

The proposals would introduce new obligations designed to mitigate harm resulting from data breaches. For example, where organisations have reasonable grounds to believe that a breach is likely to cause harm, they would be required to notify the Information Commissioner within a 72-hour window.  While the New Zealand Office of the Privacy Commissioner has made it clear that it expects a 72-hour time frame to apply in New Zealand, this requirement does not appear in the Act.

Impact on New Zealand businesses 

The Australian Privacy Act applies to New Zealand organisations carrying on business in Australia, meaning they may need to comply with the additional requirements introduced by the reforms, even where their practices comply with New Zealand law.

The practical impact is likely to be greatest for larger or data-intensive businesses that use substantial amounts of personal or behavioural information for profiling, personalisation or targeted advertising, particularly in light of the proposed fair and reasonable test and tighter restrictions on direct marketing and data trading. Businesses collecting only conventional information necessary to provide goods or services are less likely to require significant changes.

Should New Zealand adopt similar reforms?

New Zealand has not yet enacted a comparable package of broader privacy reforms but the Privacy Commissioner has advocated for change, including a right to erasure, a significantly stronger penalty regime, stronger protections for automated decision-making and greater organisational accountability (see Office of the Privacy Commissioner | Annual Report of the Privacy Commissioner 2026).

There is a good policy rationale for shifting more responsibility onto organisations. As data practices become increasingly complex, and the occurrence and threat of data breaches and cyber-attacks continue to grow, there is a legitimate question about how much more responsibility and accountability individuals can realistically expect of those who collect and hold their personal information. That does not necessarily mean New Zealand should adopt the Australian model wholesale. New Zealand already has a principles-based Privacy Act, and concepts underpinning the Australian proposal, including necessity and constraints on collection, are reflected in our existing framework.

The Australian reforms should nevertheless provide a useful comparator as New Zealand considers whether existing protections remain sufficient as technology and data practices continue to evolve. It will also be useful to see how an overarching fair-and-reasonable test operated in practice. Principles-based regulation provides flexibility as technology and data practices develop, but that flexibility can also create uncertainty for businesses about exactly where the regulatory line sits.

Get in touch with one of our experts

If you would like to discuss any aspect of these reforms, or what they may mean for your business, please contact one of our experts.

Special thanks to James Burnett for his assistance with this article

Contacts

Related Articles